Previous Pastors
Previous Pastors of Setauket Presbyterian Church
Head Pastors
Rev. Nathaniel Brewster 1665-1690
Rev. George Phillips 1697-1739
Rev. David Young 1745-1753
Rev. Benjamin Talmadge 1754-1786
Rev. Noah Wetmore 1786-1796
Rev. Zachariah Greene* 1797-1858
Rev. John Gile** 1843-1849
Rev. James S. Evans, D.D. 1850-1867
Rev. William H. Littell 1868-1904
Rev. George R. Brauer 1904-1910
Rev. Thomas J. Elms 1910-1927
Rev. Marion F. Stuart 1928-1933
Rev. Frederick E. Williams 1933-1949
Rev. Harry K. Treude 1950-1952
Rev. Donald R. Broad, D.Min. 1953-1977
Rev. Jon M. Walton, D.Min. 1978-1985
Rev. Theodore J. Wardlaw, D.Min. 1986-1991
Rev. Tony K. Wolfe, Ph.D. 1992-1997
Rev. James K. Wallace 2000-2009
Rev. Mary Barrett Speers 2013-2018
Rev. Dr. Johanna McCune Wagner 2022-present
* Pastor Emeritus 1849-1858
** Co-Pastor with Rev. Greene
Assistant and Associate Pastors
Rev. John A. Ekman 1967-1973
Rev. Pamela M. Cunningham 1973-1979
Rev. Mark L. Cooper 1979-1981
Rev. Kenneth A. B. Wells 1984-1989
Rev. Kenneth G. Page 1990-1995
Rev. Jeffery A. Geary 1996-2011
Rev. Kathryn C. Jones Calone 2012-2015
Rev. Ashley McFaul-Erwin 2019-2023
Recent Interim and Supply Pastors
Rev. Albert J. Jeandheur (Supply) 1997
Rev. Richard B. Martin (Interim) 1997-1999
Rev. Richard E. Ploth (Supply) 1999-2000
Rev. John W. Kloepfer, Ph.D. (Interim) 2009-2013
Rev. Kathryn C. Jones Calone (Interim) 2019-2022
Rev. Charles Cary (Temporary Supply) 2022